Monday, September 21, 2009

Supply or Demand?

So I attended a talk last week at Barnard College entitled 'The Economics of Slavery' by Siddharth Kara who wrote 'Sex Trafficking: Inside the Business of Modern Slavery.'  During the talk, Kara highlighted some of the conclusions of his research: namely that sex trafficking is profitable, and that it is necessary to attack the potential for profit-making in order to reduce it.  He claimed that sex trafficking is poorly understood and that organizations against sex trafficking remained underfunded.  According to Kara, there are between 27.7-30.7 million slaves this year (of course he qualified that by stating that all numbers and calculations on this subject are suspicious).  

Kara explained that there are two components to sex trafficking: the trading (supply side) and the slavery (demand side).  According to his business model of how sex trafficking functions, the three steps are acquisition, movement, and exploitation.  The main point of Kara's argument was that sex trafficking is a highly profitable business that generates a ton of profit at little real risk to the traffickers.  Policy, it seems, generally focuses on the trafficking component and often ignores the slavery factor altogether.  Kara claims that the minimal risk to traffickers is due to a confusion over the definition of trafficking as well as the high amount of corruption in enforcing anti-trafficking and slavery policy.

In conclusion, Kara's strategy for dealing with sex trafficking on a global scale is to tackle the issue from an economic perspective.  If the business is so profitable, why not reduce the traffickers' ability to profit so much such that aggregate demand will be reduced?  He claims that because supply will always be there due to gender, caste, ethnic, and other socio-economic factors, attacking the demand side is critical to dealing with this disturbing international dilemma.  This would be done by increasing the price of sex, thereby reducing consumer demand.  According to Kara, the demand curve for bought sex is highly elastic so that as the price increases only slightly, consumer demand decreases a good amount.  

There is also a need to elevate the real risk to the traffickers.  Some of the strategies Kara has for this include an international slavery intervention force, community vigilance committees that are trained and paid,, increasing the salaries of anti-trafficking police and judges, witness protection options, and an increase in penalties for slave crimes (apparently the penalty for selling cocaine is 20 times the amount than it is for trafficking people in the United States).  

I happened to really enjoy Kara's talk and I think it brought a new perspective to how to deal with sex trafficking on a global level.  It was also refreshing to see a man make this cause so central to work and life.  I did, however, have a few concerns.  While I do think that taking on the demand side of things as a strategy is critical to reducing trafficking and sex slavery, I think it is critical that we not ignore the individuals and the supply side of the story.  While it does seem almost impossible to improve gender, ethnic, caste, and socio-economic equality in the countries where most of the sex slaves are trafficked from, that does not mean that taking on those causes should be ignored altogether.  It is still the international community's responsibility to continue fighting for such changes including the empowerment of women professionally, educationally, and emotionally, and the reduction of domestic violence and violence against women in general on the part of men.  More education and information on the subject needs to be dispersed to those living in the countries receiving the sex slaves as many people living in Western Europe and the United States barely even know it exists in their respective countries.  In other words, while I do agree with Kara on many of his points (and I think I he's fantastic, don't get me wrong), I also think it's important to not limit ourselves by tackling this issue from only one side of it.  Even though equality and economic development sometimes feel like hopeless pursuits, if we start to believe they will never happen, then they truly will never happen.  

And those are my thoughts on that.

Sunday, September 20, 2009

A Warm Welcome

So this is my first post.  Very exciting.  This blog is going to be about all gender related issues I feel like bringing up.   We'll see how it goes!
  

Check out this event at Columbia University this Monday:

A Blog of Her Own: Scholarly Women on the Web

Date:September 21, 2009 from 12:30 PM to 2:30 PM
Location:Columbia University, Morningside Campus, Lerner Hall Room 555
Contact:For further information regarding this event, please contact Kathryn Pope by sending an email to or by calling 212-851-2856.

Hear from the women behind the popular blogs Bitch Ph.D., Tenured Radical, Oh! Industry, Easternblot.net, andExpression Patterns. Bitch Ph.D. author Tedra Osell is a writer, former English professor, mother, and sometime public intellectual. Claire Potter blogs as Tenured Radical and is a professor of history and American Studies at Wesleyan University. Alexandra T. Vazquez, one of three contributors to the blog Oh! Industry, is an assistant professor at the Center for African American Studies and in the Department of English at Princeton University. Eva Amsen blogs at Easternblot.net and recently completed her Ph.D. in biochemistry at the University of Toronto.

The speakers will discuss the interplay between their blogging and scholarship, attitudes towards blogging among their colleagues, how blogging should be valued in the academy, and blogging as a feminist act. The Columbia community is encouraged to send questions for the bloggers in advance to kp2002@columbia.edu.


Check out more info on this event at the link below:

http://scholcomm.columbia.edu/blog-ones-own-scholarly-women-web